B.Fernandes
VS
Mbeumo
B.Fernandes Vs Mbeumo: The Better FPL Pick
The call — Same shirt, same six fixtures, four projected points between them — and a £4.0m price gap. That's the whole Bruno Fernandes vs Bryan Mbeumo debate in one line, and it's the most interesting midfield call at Old Trafford right now.
What has not being with FFIQ cost you this season?
One squad, picked before a ball was kicked and run for six gameweeks on three transfers — no hits taken. Scored on FPL’s own results.
Your name and your FPL team name. That is all it takes, and we will have your answer before you have finished reading this sentence.
↓ Start here — your name, then your team.
No FPL password, ever. We only read what FPL already publishes.
Both are staring at a genuinely lovely run: Hull away, Ipswich at home, Everton away, then City at home, Fulham away and Spurs at home. Only the Etihad-Old Trafford clash raises an eyebrow; the rest is exactly the kind of schedule you buy United attackers for.
My numbers put Fernandes on roughly thirty-one points across those six gameweeks, Mbeumo on about twenty-seven. Fernandes is my pick, and it's not just the raw total — he's the man United's returns run through. He's on everything: set pieces, penalties, the final pass. When United score, he's usually involved, and on his day he can go massive. That's why nearly half of all managers — about 5 in 10 — already own him at £12.0m. He's template for a reason.
The honest case for Mbeumo is loud, though. At £8.0m he gets you most of Fernandes' output for two-thirds of the price, and with only about 3 in 10 managers on him, a big Mbeumo week actually moves you up your mini-league rather than keeping you level. Per pound, he's clearly the better deal — that £4.0m saved could turn a £6.0m forward into a £10.0m one elsewhere.
The caveat cuts both ways. Fernandes at £12.0m demands hauls, not steady fives, and against City that's a stretch. Mbeumo, meanwhile, is newer to this United side, and my numbers still rank him a rung below Fernandes in the pecking order for the big returns — when there's one goal in a game, Fernandes is likelier to be the man attached to it.
So here's the call. If your budget stretches, buy Fernandes — he's the higher scorer, the penalty taker, and with half the world owning him, going without is the real gamble over a run this kind. If the £12.0m breaks your structure, Mbeumo is a very good consolation, not a compromise. But given the choice between the two, my pick is Fernandes — get him in before Hull away.