Semenyo
VS
Gibbs-White
Semenyo Vs Gibbs-White: The Better FPL Pick
The call — Two midfielders, the same very kind run of fixtures, and my numbers say the higher-projected one isn't the better buy. Gibbs-White comes out of my model at around 35 points over the next six gameweeks — nearly six a week — while Semenyo sits a shade lower at about 31. Read only that line and you'd sign the Forest man…
What has not being with FFIQ cost you this season?
One squad, picked before a ball was kicked and run for six gameweeks on three transfers — no hits taken. Scored on FPL’s own results.
Your name and your FPL team name. That is all it takes, and we will have your answer before you have finished reading this sentence.
↓ Start here — your name, then your team.
No FPL password, ever. We only read what FPL already publishes.
Here's the case. Semenyo at £8.5m is the attacking piece at Manchester City with the clearest route to returns, and City's run is about as gentle as it gets: Coventry at home, then trips to Manchester United and a home game against Sunderland, before Liverpool away is the one genuinely tough afternoon, followed by Ipswich at home and Villa away. In a side that racks up chances like City do, he's the sort of player who ticks along at five-plus most weeks and can go massive when everything clicks. About 2 in 10 managers already have him — popular, but not yet everywhere.
Gibbs-White is the tidier, steadier option. £7.9m, hardly anyone owns him — roughly 1 in 10 — and his fixtures are just as friendly: Spurs at home, Villa away, Coventry at home, Palace away, then Arsenal at home and Ipswich away. My numbers actually give him the higher week-to-week points, and if you're hunting a cheap differential who quietly delivers, he's a genuinely good one. The honest caveat on Semenyo is exactly that: he costs £0.6m more and projects slightly fewer total points over the window.
But the reason he still sits top of my list is the size of his good weeks. Gibbs-White's returns are steady; Semenyo's come with the kind of upside that wins you a rank swing — and with Liverpool away the only ugly fixture in six, the platform is there.
If the budget is tight, Gibbs-White won't let you down. But if you can stretch to it, buy Semenyo — he's my pick of the two.